Movie Review: Unfrosted

The story of the new Netflix movie “Unfrosted” reminds any screenwriter or standup comedian that writing a screenplay is just about the most difficult art form, but writing a comedy screenplay is about twice as difficult as just writing a screenplay.

Unfrosted, which is a parody of the creation of Kellog's Pop-Tarts, is the first movie Jerry Seinfeld has written, directed, and starred in. He is arguably of the most successful and prolific standup comedians of all time - but writing jokes for a standup act is not the same as writing a comedy screenplay. In the history of movies, only one comedy, Annie Hall, released in 1977 has won best picture. In my opinion, in the last 50 years only two other movies can be considered outstanding comedies at the level of Annie Hall; "My Cousin Vinnie", released in 1992 and "When Harry Met Sally" released in 1989. A great movie comedy is extremely rare and hard to write.

Seinfeld wrote Unfrosted with two other screenwriters Spike Feresten and Andy Robin and while watching this extremely bad movie, I was amazed considering 3 screenwriters and a very large list of known actors that nobody noticed how extremely unfunny this entire film is. It seemed that nobody dared to say, “This is not working, this is not funny”. The dialogue and situations seem to be more about an attempt to force bad jokes on the audience, and less about creating a creative, funny and interesting comedy movie. There is a scene where Jerry Seinfeld runs through a barn with flatulating cows on both sides of him. Why would someone like Jerry Seinfield think this is either funny or appropriate?

The best review of this film that I have read is from critic Richard Roper who wrote: “Jerry Seinfeld’s Netflix movie “Unfrosted,” an astonishingly unfunny, deeply weird, live-action cartoon that is so clear-the-room dreadful it almost plays like a horror movie. “Unfrosted” is so consistently awful it makes the aforementioned “Flamin’ Hot” seem like “The Social Network.” If there was a thing called the IMDB Witness Protection Program whereby you could get your name taken off the credits of a particular project, this would be that project. “Unfrosted” is one of the worst films of the decade so far . Unfortunately I agree 100% with all of these comments.

This movie stars many former alumni of Saturday Night Live, Mikey Day, Kyle Mooney, Fred Armisen and Bobby Moynihan and a very large supporting case including Jim Gaffigan, Christian Slater, Sarah Cooper, Amy Schumer, Max Greenfield, Melissa McCarthy and Sebastian Maniscalco. I found this large and famous cast even more insane when you realize this many people agreed to make this movie, and nobody read the script?

I agree that the words “Pop Tart” sound funny, but to make a 2-hour movie parody about the invention of the Pop Tart in 1963 entirely because the words sound funny, makes no sense. Hopefully Jerry Seinfeld will get another chance at a new film and hopefully will co-write it with an experienced and great screenwriter like Aaron Sorkin or even his close friend Larry David. Unfrosted is one idea and screenplay that never should have been greenlighted in the first place and is one of the worst comedy movies of all time.

The Rotten Tomatoes ratings for Unfrosted are a too high 43%, with my rating only 10% and a run for your life miss this waste of two hours.